We slide into the depths of 2016 carried by the momentum (and dare I say popularity?) of last year’s pizza challenge. It is fun, after all, to find “the best” food categories throughout a city with overwhelming and growing selection. So, we decided to find the best burger in Philadelphia during the late winter and early spring of 2016. This poses a greater challenge as it is a well- known fact that Philly knows its burgers and there are plenty to be had around the city. We cultivated out list using a combination of social media, recommendations, personal experiences, and major publications (Philadelphia Inquirer, Philadelphia Magazine). For this challenge, we are considerably more specific than our pizza challenge; we’re just looking at the burgers themselves. We’re not concerned about atmosphere, drink selections, desserts, or the sides that accompany the burger. Some places have one burger on the menu, others have multiple. We will select the one or two items that have the most appeal or popularity per the restaurant staff. Our selected eateries are spread throughout the city as a matter or circumstance, not intention. We will give an overall evaluation based on the following: meat quality & preparation, bun, toppings, and cheese when applicable. We will set a standard of “medium rare” burger temperature when allowed. So, get ready to get enticed!
Our listing is a ranking of lowest to highest.
12. Varga Bar- 941 Spruce Street
Kobe burger with applewood smoked bacon, cheddar, caramelized onions, greens, heirloom tomato and optional fried egg make up the construct of this rather average/ordinary burger. Points are lost when you order a medium rare burger but it’s presented well done. On the other hand, when delivered as ordered (as was the case with Cassie’s burger) the meat is quite good with the sweet bread and onions add a good contrast to the meat.
11. Rex 1516- 1516 South Street
The burger at Rex is the winner of Philadelphia Magazine’s Best Burger 2015. Well prepared with bacon, homemade pimento cheese, onions and bibb lettuce on a sweet bun. The optional fried egg is what made the burger the winner this past year. All together, it’s very tasty, a bit of a mess, but rather busy. The strong flavors of the bacon and pimento drown out the flavors of the meat. The lettuce added absolutely nothing. The highlight has to be the bun, a nice addition of sweetness that is meant to balance out the spicy of the pimento cheese, which is pretty spicy.
10. Rouge- 208 South 18th Street
This is often on the tops of the city’s best burger list. A long time favorite of Robert’s, there were high hopes for the Rouge Burger to top the list. The 1/2 pound patty comes with caramelized onions and gruyere on brioche. The bun is sweet with sear that renders it a tad salty. The caramelized onions and cheese are a couple of the best accompaniments to a burger on the challenge; it adds its own special flavor without overwhelming the taste of the beef. Preparation, however, was a bit of an issue. On this unfortunate time at Rouge one of the two ordered burgers was seriously undercooked. Ordered medium, this burger came out with room-temperature rare beef in the middle of the patty. Inconsistency can certainly affect one’s opinion on a place and this was enough to make it almost intolerable.
9. Mak Attack- Lucky's Last Chance, 4421 Main Street
2 griddle fried 4 oz. paddies plus mac and cheese on a Lisco’s roll. Initially I thought I was eating a burger with a side of macaroni and cheese. By the second half of the burger, I felt like was eating a very cheesy burger. The macaroni added a texture to the cheese which made it seem creamier.
8. Pub & Kitchen- 1946 Lombard Street
Putting years of old nostalgia aside and forgetting the old burgers from here, we went in with a clean mind and clean slate. The Pub and Kitchen burger comes with two patties, lightly pickled cucumbers, lettuce, onion, and cheddar cheese on a more traditional bun. This is the closest to good old fashion burger that we tried and they do old fashioned well. Juicy meat and just the right amount of cheese means no added ketchup is required for this guy.
7. House Grind Burger- Blue Duck, 2859 Holme Ave.
Beef patty, lettuce, tomato, onion on brioche have all the accompaniments of a standard burger and that is basically what this is. Better than average, the meat was well prepared and the bun provided some sweetness and body to absorb all the juices.
6. Sketch- 413 East Girard Ave.
This is a no frills dive where you can draw and color a picture while you wait and potentially have the illustration added to the massive mosaic on the walls. The menu includes kobe beef, plain beef, turkey as well as specials including bison and buffalo chicken. The sauces range of house made ketchup and chipotle sauce to green goddess and siracha based sauces. They are free, you can try as many as you want, and anything goes. A must have starter is the cheese fries with a nice mixture of cheeses and green onions that add a great touch. We both got slightly different but relatively standard burgers made of beef (kobe beef and beef with onions) with all the toppings and cheese of choice (options are american, chedder, provolone, and swiss). The all american burger with a hipster twist of sauces. Not the best meat on the menu or the best burgers. But the atmosphere and the specials have us wanting to go back anyways.
5. PB & Bacon- Lucky's Last Chance, 4421 Main St.
Two 4 ounce burger patties with cheese, bacon, and peanut butter on top with a side of raspberry jelly doesn’t sound all that appealing. But when the bacon is done right and the jelly is house made (not to mention a very appropriate bun to hold things together) it is amazing. These are by far some of the best toppings we experienced. The meat is not the center of attention, nor is it meant to be. Its simply there to complete.
4. Standard Tap- 901 North Front Street
This has been on many lists as one of the best for years. A solid staple of Northern Liberties, Standard Tap boasts one burger and only needs one. The Standard burger comes simply with toppings of cheddar cheese, lettuce, onion, and green tomatoes. The burger was nicely seared and crispy on the outside but tender, juicy on the inside. The addition of thinly sliced green tomatoes added a sour-sweetness.
3. Beast of the Northeast Burger- Blue Duck, 2859 Holme Ave.
This patty is a combination of beef and wild boar. The addition of the wild boar makes the meat lighter, less fatty but still has plenty of flavor. Throw on some gouda, tomato jam, bacon and sriracha-coated onion rings and you have a quite a plethora of flavors and textures; sweet, spicy, salty; it’s all included in a given bite. But here’s the kicker: these very different flavors blend well on this particular sandwich. We’ve tried many burgers that throw a bunch of strong flavors on top of a patty. This version, however, makes all the flavors balance very well with each other and the meat. Many burger flippers have tried but The Blue Duck succeeded.
2. Kensington Quarters- 1310 Frankford Ave.
Kensington Quarters was voted “Best Butcher 2015” by Philadelphia Magazine; it is no wonder their ground kobe beef burger is generating some much press. The meat is top notch and the toppings of cheddar and onions do not overwhelm the meat. All of this is in what has now become the only way to eat a burger, a brioche bun. They clearly go to great pains to highlight this fact with the meat being done just right and a large patty to make it the obvious center of attention.
1. Village Whiskey- 118 S. 20th Street
A quiet Sunday early dinner allowed us to sit nicely in the bar area at Village Whiskey where reservations are not accepted. With one of the best additional accompaniments menu for burgers, this one packs a lot of promise. We opted for simple additional of Jasper Hill Cheddar for one and chèvre for the other. With toppings of crisp (and i mean crisp and fresh) bibb lettuce, tomato, and unfortunately thousand island dressing, the meat does most of the talking and the talking is good. The chèvre cheese was by far the better addition, making one of us extremely jealous of the other but still very satisfied nonetheless. Prepared just as requested with meat that just melts in your mouth, going back for another shouldn’t be too hard.
 |
The winner- Village Whiskey's Village Burger with chèvre |